INTRODUCTION

The second stage is a critical period of labor1. The supervision of the birth position during the second stage of labor, as an essential element of delivery management, has a significant influence in encouraging spontaneous birth and enhancing the satisfaction of childbirth2. Guidelines for childbirth issued by various international organizations make it abundantly clear that during the second stage of labor, women are encouraged to select their own birth positions, with the upright position being preferred and the supine or lithotomy positions being discouraged3. Upright position refers to a position in which the line connecting the centers of the third and fifth lumbar vertebrae is at an angle greater than 45° to the horizontal and the third lumbar vertebra is higher than the fifth lumbar vertebra, including walking, standing, sitting, squatting, and kneeling positions4. Clarifying the methods and considerations for performing upright positions during the second stage of labor is an important factor that may affect pregnancy outcome.

Labor in the upright position offers unique anatomical and physiological advantages. The upright position effectively uses fatal gravity to facilitate descent and increase the size of the pelvic outlet, while enhancing uterine contractions and avoiding intrauterine hypoxia by reducing uterine compression of the abdominal aorta and inferior vena cava5. Due to these advantages, the upright position during labor may contribute to a smooth vaginal delivery and improve outcomes for both mother and infant, especially during the second stage of labor6. A Cochrane evaluation of second stage of upright labor positions in women without epidural anesthesia showed a reduction in the ratio of instrumental labor and episiotomy7. Gupta et al.8 also found that the duration of the second stage of labor was significantly shorter using the upright position in women without epidural analgesia.

Studies investigating the management of the second stage of labor while in the upright position have been published throughout the previous few decades8,9. Even though the upright position has been given priority by a number of guidelines, the majority of current studies concentrate on assessing the efficacy of interventions for delivery in the upright position, with evidence that is more general and dispersed8,10. Additionally, there is a lack of thorough and systematic guidance for clinical practice, which may be confusing to clinical decision-makers when implementing the upright position11. To our knowledge, only very few published recommendations have specifically addressed the use of the upright position based on the results of the current study. The optimum way to condense the available implementation options was found to be evidence summary. In order to bridge the research gap, we performed a literature review on laboring in the upright position. We then evaluated and consolidated what was known with the goal of giving midwives and other clinical staff a reference point for instructing pregnant women on how to correctly use the upright position labor technique.

METHODS

Research strategy

This review was guided by the ‘6S’ evidence hierarchy; we searched a range of sources3,5,6,8,10,12-49 including Computer Decision Making Systems, Guidelines database, Professional Associations and library databases; details can be found in Table 1. Our search combined Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) with free-text terms related to birth positions during the second stage of labor, such as ‘maternity/pregnant/delivery/stage of labor/second stage of labor’, ‘birth position/free position/upright position/seating position/squatting position/semi recumbent position/kneeling position/standing posture/walking/intrapartum management’. Because indexing conventions vary across platforms, we tailored the search syntax for each database (see Supplementary file Table 1 for full strategies). The retrieval period covered the period from the database’s creation until September 2024. Evidence was extracted from the included literature, and its original source was then tracked down. During the evidence extraction process, we noted that the primary studies cited by the included evidence sources were all published before January 2019. To ensure that our evidence base reflected the most recent findings, we therefore conducted an additional search for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) published between January 2019 and September 2024. As this study involved secondary analysis of publicly available literature, it was exempt from institutional review board approval.

Table 1

Literature research databases

CategoriesDatabases
Computer decision-making systemsUpToDate; British Medical Journal (BMJ) best practice
GuidelinesQueensland Health; World Health Organization (WHO); Registered Nurses’ Association of Ontario (RNAO); National Institute for Health; Clinical Excellence (NICE); Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN); Guidelines International Network (GIN); National Guideline Clearinghouse (NGC); China Guideline Clearinghouse (CGC); Medlive
Professional associationsAmerican College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG); Chinese Maternal and Child Health Association (CMCHA); Obstetrics and Gynecology Branch of Chinese Medical Association (Obstetrics Group)
LibraryCochrane Library; PubMed; SinoMed; Embase; CINAHL; Epistemonikos; CNKI; Wanfang database; Nursing consult; DynaMed

[i] Comprehensive list of databases searched for evidence on upright positions in second-stage labor management, showing initial hits and duplicate removal. Searches covered publications from database inception to September 2024, with additional focus on randomized controlled trials (RCTs) published between January 2019 and September 2024. Search strategies combined MeSH terms and free-text keywords (Supplementary file S1 for full details).

Inclusion and exclusion criteria

We included studies that addressed the management of upright delivery in the second stage of labor, including implementation strategies, preventive measures, and other related topics, with the research subject being women in the second stage of labor. The following were the inclusion requirements: 1) Literature types included guidelines, best practices, evidence summaries, systematic reviews, practice recommendations, expert consensus, and RCTs; and 2) Languages were limited to Chinese and English. The exclusion criteria were: 1) Duplicate publications from multiple institutions; 2) Translated versions or updated literature; 3) Study type as a research proposal, report, or abstract; and 4) Incomplete information or full text inaccessible.

Selection process

Following PRISMA guidelines, the three reviewers independently screened records using EndNote X9. We first employed its automatic duplicate detection feature to identify potential duplicates, then manually verified and removed 694 duplicate records from an initial pool of 14576 citations. An additional 176 records were excluded for other reasons, including full-text unavailability, non-compliance with our eligibility criteria, conference abstracts, and publications in languages other than English or Chinese. Prior to full screening, we calibrated our approach by jointly reviewing a random 20% sample of titles and abstracts, achieving substantial agreement (κ=0.87). The remaining records were then divided among reviewers for independent assessment. Of the 1214 articles retrieved in full text, discrepancies in eligibility judgments were discussed in consensus meetings facilitated by the senior reviewer. Ultimately, 43 publications were included, with exclusions systematically documented and cross-checked against the ‘6S’ evidence hierarchy, ensuring a transparent and reproducible selection.

Evaluation of the literature’s quality

The Clinical Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II (AGREE II) was used to assess the guidelines. The Critical Appraisal for Summaries of Evidence (CASE) was utilized for rating evidence summaries. The Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) Centre for Evidence-Based Health Care’s equivalent assessment standards were applied for scoring expert consensus, systematic reviews, and RCTs. Two researchers independently appraised the quality of the literature. Each of the three had been instructed in evidence-based methods, and disagreements were resolved through iterative discussion until consensus was reached.

Evidence integration, extraction, and assessment

Two researchers independently extracted data on intervention components, outcomes, and contextual factors, with a third reviewer auditing a random subset for consistency. When evidence from multiple sources converged, we integrated findings thematically using a descriptive scoping synthesis approach. The synthesized results were organized into evidence summary tables, and no quantitative meta-analysis was performed. In cases of conflict, we prioritized higher quality, more recent, or more authoritative sources. According to the type of study, each piece of evidence was ranked from one to five using the JBI Evidence Preclassification and Recommendation Levels of Evidence (2014), with one representing the greatest level and five the lowest level.

RESULTS

Results of the literature review and general information of included studies

The PRISMA flow diagram-based literature retrieval process is shown in Supplementary file Figure 1. In this study, a total of 14576 articles were retrieved, and 1214 articles were located after two researchers independently investigated the articles’ titles and abstracts; 43 articles were eventually included after reading every page of text, encompassing 6 articles12-17 (14.0%) on clinical decision-making, 4 papers5,18-20 (9.3%) that provided an evidence summary, 17 articles (39.5%) on guidelines3,21-36, 12 papers (27.9%)6,8,10,37-45 that underwent a systematic review and 4 papers (9.3%)46-49 that were RCTs; the time span of included literature was 2010–2023, of which 65.1% were published after 2020. There were 7 Chinese articles and 36 English articles. Guidelines were sourced from multiple organizations, including Queensland Health (n=6), SOGC (n=2), RCOG (n=2), WHO (n=2), ACOG (n=1), NICE (n=1), and others (n=3). Of the 12 systematic reviews, 4 were from China, and 4 were from Europe. All 4 RCTs were from Asia. Table 2 displays the broad context of the included material.

Table 2

General characteristics of included studies (N=43)

NumberAuthorEvidence typeYearLiterature themeSourceReference
1HofmeyrBest clinical practice guideline2022Delivery of the singleton fetus in breech presentationUpToDate12
2Funai and NorwitzBest clinical practice guideline2022Labor and delivery: management of the normal second stageUpToDate13
3StuebeBest clinical practice guideline2022Continuous labor support by a doulaUpToDate14
4Ehsanipoor and SatinBest clinical practice guideline2021Labor: diagnosis and management of a prolonged second stageUpToDate15
5Caughey and TildenBest clinical practice guideline2021Nonpharmacologic approaches to management of labor painUpToDate16
6Hofmeyr and Singata-MadlikiBest clinical practice guideline2020The second stage of laborCINAHL17
7Gimovsky and BerghellaEvidence summary2022Evidence-based labor management: second stage of labor (part 4)PubMed5
8MoolaEvidence summary2021Perineal trauma: childbirthJBI18
9MinooeeEvidence summary2021Labor: second stageJBI19
10Feng et al.Evidence summary2021Best evidence summary of nursing measures in the second and third stages of normal delivery (Chinese)Wanfang database20
11Queensland Clinical GuidelinesGuideline2023Intrapartum pain managementQueensland21
12Queensland Clinical GuidelinesGuideline2022Normal birthQueensland22
13Queensland Clinical GuidelinesGuideline2022Rheumatic heart disease and pregnancyQueensland23
14Queensland Clinical GuidelinesGuideline2021Obesity and pregnancy (including post bariatric surgery)Queensland24
15Dore and EhmanGuideline2020Fetal health surveillance: Intrapartum consensus guideline (SOGC)Medlive25
16Chinese Maternal and Child Health Care Association Midwife BranchGuideline2020Clinical practice guideline of normal birth (Chinese)Medlive26
17Murphy et al.Guideline2020Assisted vaginal birth (RCOG)Medlive27
18Ministry of Public Health QatarGuideline2020Antenatal, intrapartum and postnatal care in low-risk pregnancyGIN28
19Queensland Clinical GuidelinesGuideline2019Intrapartum fetal surveillance (IFS)Queensland29
20Queensland Clinical GuidelinesGuideline2018Perineal careQueensland30
21WHO 2018Guideline2018Intrapartum care for a positive childbirth experienceWHO3
22American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists’ Committee on Obstetric PracticeGuideline2017Approaches to limit intervention during labor and birth (ACOG)Medlive31
23Impey et al.Guideline2017Management of breech presentation (RCOG)Medlive32
24Lee et al.Guideline2016Management of spontaneous labor at term in healthy women (SOGC)Medlive33
25Roberts et al.Guideline2014Intrapartum care for healthy women and babies (NICE)GIN34
26WHO 2014Guideline2014WHO recommendations for augmentation of laborWHO36
27Mambourg et al.Guideline2010Guideline relative to low-risk birth (Belgian Health Care Knowledge Centre)GIN35
28Zang et al.Systematic review2021Benefits and risks of upright positions during the second stage of labor: an overview of systematic reviewsCINAHL6
29Zang et al.Systematic review2020Effects of upright positions during the second stage of labor for women without epidural analgesia: a meta-analysisCINAHL37
30Mirzakhani et al.Systematic review2020The effect of maternal position on maternal, fetal and neonatal outcomes: a systematic reviewCINAHL38
31Healy et al.Systematic review2020How do midwives facilitate women to give birth during physiological second stage of labor? A systematic reviewCINAHL39
32Dokmak et al.Systematic review2020Squatting position in the second stage of labor: a systematic review and meta-analysisCINAHL40
33Berta et al.Systematic review2019Effect of maternal birth positions on duration of second stage of labor: systematic review and meta-analysis.CINAHL41
34Ying et al.Systematic review2018Influence of different delivering positions on perineal outcomes: a systematic review (Chinese)CNKI42
35Jin et al.Systematic review2019Effects of 7 positions in the second stage of labor: a network meta-analysis (Chinese)CNKI43
36Barrowclough et al.Systematic review2022Maternal postures for fetal malposition in labor for improving the health of mothers and their infantsCochrane44
37Gupta et al.Systematic review2017Position in the second stage of labor for women without epidural anesthesiaCochrane8
38Rocha et al.Systematic review2020Upright positions in childbirth and the prevention of perineal lacerations: a systematic review and meta-analysisEpistemonikos45
39Walker et al.Systematic review2018Maternal position in the second stage of labor for women with epidural anesthesiaPubMed10
40Zhu et al.RCT2021Clinical application of vertical position combined with lateral position for promoting natural delivery (Chinese)SinoMed46
41Shedmake and WakodeRCT2021A hospitalbased randomized controlled trial—Comparing the outcome of normal delivery between squatting and lying down positions during laborPubMed47
42FengRCT2020Application effect of different posture nursing for the full-term pregnancy and delivery of elderly parturient women with continuous occipitotransverse position and occipitoposterior position (Chinese)SinoMed48
43Wang et al.RCT2020Study on the effect of standing forward tilt and pelvic swing in the second stage of labor (Chinese)Wanfang database49

[i] JBI: Joanna Briggs Institute. GIN: Guidelines International Network. WHO: World Health Organization. ACOG: American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. NICE: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. RCOG: Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. SOGC: Society of Obstetricians and Gynecologists of Canada. WHO: World Health Organization. RCT: randomized controlled trial.

Results of literature quality evaluation

Quality evaluation results of the best clinical practice guideline

Five12-16 of the six best clinical practice guidelines were from UpToDate and one17 from CINAHL. All were judged by three independent reviewers using the CASE tool to be of high methodological quality and suitable for inclusion. It is noteworthy that only one guideline16 offered a clear hierarchy of evidence and none provided a fully documented search strategy. Overall, these guidelines scored well on transparency and clinical applicability, offering clear, actionable recommendations. However, three critical limitations were identified: 1) None fully reported databases, search terms, or screening processes, raising concerns about reproducibility; 2) 83% did not use a standardized framework like GRADE or JBI to grade evidence; and 3) Particularly in summaries addressing specialized positions (e.g. breech presentation), institutional affiliations may have influenced conclusions. The detailed methodological evaluation of best clinical practice guidelines by CASE is shown in Supplementary file Table 2.1.

Quality evaluation results of the evidence summaries

Four5,18-20 evidence summaries were utilized, with two from JBI, one from PubMed, and one from CNKI, all deemed high quality. Across the board, they showed strong transparency in authorship, clarity of recommendations, appropriate citations, and applicability to patients across all four topics. Most also featured comprehensive search methods and editorial clarity, though two fell short in disclosing reviewer/editor roles or fully detailing their search protocols. Importantly, all employed graded evidence systems and remained current, unbiased, and clinically pertinent. While minor inconsistencies in reporting persist, the overall methodological rigor is solid. See Supplementary file Table 2.2 for details.

Quality evaluation results of the guidelines

Seventeen guidelines have been employed in this research. Sixteen of the guidelines were rated as ‘A’ quality and one was rated as ‘B’ quality based on AGREE II assessment. Performance was strongest in ‘Scope and Purpose’ (92.59–100%) and ‘Clarity of Presentation’ (88.89–100%), but more variable in ‘Stakeholder Involvement’ (56.94–100%) and ‘Applicability’ (56.94–97.22%). High-quality guidelines excelled in methodological rigor (>95%) and inclusion of practical implementation tools. In contrast, lower scoring guidelines lacked transparent evidence selection and resource analysis. Recurring issues included limited patient involvement (50% of guidelines), weak linkage between evidence and recommendations (30%), and absent update mechanisms (40%). The results of the methodological evaluation of the guidelines are detailed in Table 3.

Table 3

Methodological quality assessment of included guidelines using AGREE II (N=17)

GuidelinesSourceStandardized scores in each area (%)≥60%
field
number
n
≤30%
field
number
n
Quality
Scope and
purpose
Involved
personnel
Preciseness
of guideline
development
Clarity of
presentation
ApplicabilityIndependence
of writing
Intrapartum pain management21Queensland92.59100.0087.50100.0094.44100.0060A
Normal birth22Queensland100.0098.1588.19100.0077.7891.6760A
Rheumatic heart disease and pregnancy23Queensland92.5992.5986.8194.4494.4494.4460A
Obesity and pregnancy (including post bariatric surgery)24Queensland100.0094.4486.8198.1595.8397.2260A
Fetal health surveillance: intrapartum consensus guideline25Medlive100.0090.7489.5890.7480.5697.2260A
Clinical practice guideline of normal birth (Chinese)26Medlive100.0096.3063.8988.8956.9480.5650B
Assisted vaginal birth27Medlive98.1590.7487.50100.0093.06100.0060A
Antenatal, intrapartum and postnatal care in low risk pregnancy28GIN100.00100.0095.1498.1575.0091.6760A
Intrapartum fetal surveillance (IFS)29Queensland98.1590.7483.3396.3093.06100.0060A
Perineal care30Queensland98.1598.1590.9798.1593.0691.6760A
Intrapartum care for a positive childbirth experience3WHO100.00100.0096.53100.0097.22100.0060A
Approaches to limit intervention during labor and birth31Medlive100.0094.4490.97100.0083.33100.0060A
Management of breech presentation (RCOG)32Medlive100.0094.4485.42100.0083.3386.1160A
Management of spontaneous labor at term in healthy women33Medlive100.0096.3088.1994.4463.8988.8960A
Intrapartum care for healthy women and babies34GIN94.4494.4481.9494.4483.3386.1160A
WHO recommendations for augmentation of labour36WHO100.00100.0093.06100.0088.89100.0060A
Guideline relative to low risk birth35GIN98.1596.3097.2290.7479.1794.4460A

[i] Quality scores of 17 clinical guidelines evaluated via AGREE II instrument across six domains (scope/purpose, stakeholder involvement, rigor of development, etc.). Scores are reported as percentages. *Number of domains in which a guideline scored ≥60% or ≤30%. Quality A: all six domains scored ≥60%; B: ≥3 domains scored between 30% and 60%; C: ≥3 domains scored <30%. Of the 17 guidelines, 16 were rated A and 1 was rated B due to an applicability domain score <60%.

Quality evaluation results of the systematic reviews

A total of twelve systematic reviews were included, with two8,44 from the Cochrane Library, six7,37-41 from CINAHL, one11 from PubMed, one45 from Epistemonikos and two42,43 from CNKI. The JBI appraisal of 12 systematic reviews on maternal positions during the second stage of labor indicated that all studies clearly stated research questions, applied appropriate inclusion criteria, and used rigorous data extraction, with recommendations aligned to evidence and future research. However, 30% of studies had incomplete search resources, 25% omitted publication bias assessment, one study lacked dual-reviewer appraisal 45, and one study ambiguously described synthesis methods39. Further details appear in Supplementary file Table 2.4.

Quality evaluation results of the RCTs

Because the systematic reviews we identified mostly drew on studies published before January 2019, we supplemented the evidence base with 19 RCTs published between January 2019 and September 2024. Ultimately, four RCTs46-49 were used to assess the quality of the literature using the JBI instrument. As expected for non-pharmacological interventions involving positioning, none employed blinding. The implementation protocol for allocation concealment in the study by Zhu et al.46 was not clearly described, and the study by Shedmake and Wakode47 did not describe in detail how the randomization grouping was conducted and the allocation concealment; considering the more complete design and overall superior quality of these two studies, inclusion was granted. The studies conducted by Feng48 and Wang et al.49 were excluded because they lacked reasonable research designs, failed to execute stochastic grouping and allocation concealment, and failed to adequately characterize the therapies. Ultimately, only 2 of the 4 RCTs were deemed methodologically sound enough to contribute evidence points to the final synthesis. Full appraisal results are available in Supplementary file Table 2.5.

Result of evidence summary

After a thorough process of literature retrieval, quality evaluation, evidence extraction, and grading, we identified 35 usable pieces of evidence. Through inductive analysis, these were synthesized into nine overarching themes: education, selection, implementation, assessment and monitoring, staff training, midwife assistance, family engagement, facility configuration, and environment creation. The key points include: 1) Education prioritization (Evidence Level 1a–1c), focusing on informed choice and maternal autonomy; 2) Adaptive implementation, adjusting positions based on maternal preference with risk monitoring; 3) Support measures, such as access to equipment (e.g. birth stools, exercise balls), targeted staff training, and active family engagement; 4) Special population management, including women with epidural analgesia, obesity or coexisting medical conditions; and 5) Evidence variability, with stronger evidence in education (Evidence Level 1a) and operational guidance relying on expert consensus (Level 5b). The levels of evidence and the recommendation level are shown in Table 4.

Table 4

Evidence-based strategies for upright positions in second-stage labor: classification and recommendation levels

CategoriesEvidence contentsEvidence
level
Education level1. The advantages and risks of an upright delivery during labor should be properly informed to pregnant women.1a
2. The pregnant woman should be informed about the potential benefits and risks associated with different delivery positions before making a decision. This allows her to make an informed choice.1b
3. Women should be encouraged to choose the childbirth position that they find most comfortable and taught about all available positions, encouraging them to choose each one voluntarily.1c
4. Whether or not epidural analgesia is used, women should be informed of the benefits of upright delivery and encouraged to choose the most comfortable upright delivery position.1a
Selection5. An upright delivery position should be taken according to the mother’s wishes.5b
6. In the second stage of labor, it is recommended that women do not take a supine or semi-supine position.5b
7. Support women giving birth by facilitating comfortable position in which the genital structures can be clearly observed.1b
8. Midwives and obstetricians are encouraged to apply upright positions depending on women’s preferences and labor progress but should take measures to prevent perineal trauma.5b
9. If no fetal manipulation or complications are anticipated, parturients should push in almost any position that they find comfortable.1c
Implementation10. Attention should be paid to the length of time a woman spends in a certain position. Prolonged use of the birth stool, sitting, lithotomy and squatting positions should be avoided.1b
11. When combined with delayed pushing, maternal position changes every 20–30 minutes in passive second stage to assist birth.1c
12. Do not advocate delivery bed too early, it is recommended that it is safer during the head visible on vulval gapping.5b
13. When need for fetal manipulation or when optimal surgical exposure is anticipated, however, a semi-recumbent position (trunk tilted forwards up to 30 degrees to the horizontal) or lithotomy position is advantageous.1c
14. Women can stand or kneel and lean their upper bodies over the ball, which can provide comfortable support of the torso or back.1a
15. Placing the ball beneath the upper leg of the side-lying parturient using epidural analgesia to shorten their labor.1c
16. Encourage overweight women to remain mobile with adequate rest periods, moving requires extra effort and difficulty may cause embarrassment. Provide emotional support to women.5b
17. Maternal mobility can be limited when women are connected to equipment, unable to support themselves due to pain medication, or asked to limit movement because of the need for monitoring or because of institutional culture or provider preferences.4b
18. Squatting may be offered to women in the second stage of labor in cases where accelerated labor may be required.1c
19. Besides self-initiated comfort-seeking movements, caregivers can suggest specific positions to accelerate labor progress or correct a fetal or maternal problem (e.g. fetal heart rate decelerations or malposition, maternal hypotension). No one position is advised.5b
20. It is recommended to encourage the parturient to adopt the position that she finds the most comfortable for pushing, provided the fetal heart rate remains normal. When the fetal heart rate is less than 100 times/min or more than 160 times/min, the pregnant woman should be instructed to lie on the left side or change the position, take oxygen, dynamically detect fetal heart changes, and notify the doctor.5b
21. Pregnant women with combined rheumatic heart disease push in left lateral rather than supine, lessens cardiovascular changes and improves preload. Avoid prolonged lithotomy positioning.5b
Assessment and monitoring22. Upright positions are recommended to be used depending on women’s preferences and labor progress, but should also be carefully monitored especially in women with epidural analgesia.5b
23. BMI greater than 40 kg/m2 recommend continuous fetal monitoring (CFM). Wireless/beltless monitoring may enhance the woman’s comfort and mobility.5b
24. Discuss the woman’s plans and support normal birth strategies following neuraxial analgesia. Follow local protocols to support active positioning/mobility after an individual mobility assessment, including: 1) Bilateral straight leg raises against resistance; 2) Supervised stepping on a step stool with either leg and taking a step; 3) Satisfactory trial of walking with a clinician. Always accompany when repositioning (to a weight bearing position) or mobilizing. If immobile, incorporate pressure injury prevention strategies.5b
25. Ambulation remains an important component of care during labor when electronic fetal monitoring (EFM) is being used. When possible, support maternal upright positions, ambulation (such as with the patient standing beside the bed, squatting, kneeling) and hydrotherapy. Where available, use wireless and waterproof technology that allows position changes, hydrotherapy, and movement during labor and pushing.1b
26. Women with back pain should be advised to avoid maintain an upright posture.5b
27. Frequent position changes during labor to enhance maternal comfort and promote optimal fetal positioning can be supported as long as adopted positions allow appropriate maternal and fetal monitoring and treatments and are not contraindicated by maternal medical or obstetric complications.5b
Staff training28. Health care professionals accustomed to supporting women to give birth in recumbent positions would require training on how to support women to give birth in an upright position.5b
Midwife assistance29. Midwives provide neutral counselling to women in labor positions.1c
30. Support from the midwife is important for the correct and consistent use of the upright position during labor.1c
31. Midwives attends to the physical comfort of the pregnant woman by providing assistance with positioning.1a
Family engagement32. Family members are encouraged to attend the birth.5b
Facility configuration33.Provide space and equipment to support use of active positioning and movement, such as bed bars, birth chair or stool, birth ball, cushion, etc.1c
34.Upright positions do not necessarily require additional props (e.g. birth cushions).5b
Environment creation35. Reduce environmental disturbances and allow pregnant women to change positions and rest.5b

[i] JBI evidence levels: Level 1 = experimental designs (RCTs and their syntheses); Level 2 = quasi-experimental; Level 3 = observational (cohort/case-control); Level 4 = case series/reports; Level 5 = expert opinion/consensus. Within each level, the sub-letters (a, b, c, d) denote specific study designs: a = systematic reviews of the respective study type; b = individual studies of that type; c = quasi-experimental or controlled non-randomized studies; d (where applicable) = case series or case reports. Full definitions are detailed in the JBI 2014 framework. Synthesis of 35 evidence items into 9 practice categories, with JBI evidence levels (1 = highest, 5 = lowest). Conflicts were resolved by prioritizing higher quality, more recent or more authoritative sources.

DISCUSSION

We interpret the main findings of our evidence synthesis on upright positions in the second stage of labor, focusing on four key themes: informed choice, implementation safety, support systems, and evidence gaps.

Providing pregnant women with information on benefits and risks of labor in upright position

Current evidence highlights the importance of systematically informing pregnant women about the benefits and risks of upright positions during labor (Level 1a). Studies show that upright positions in non-epidural women shorten the second stage, reduce episiotomy rates and decrease instrumental delivery needs, albeit with increased risks of blood loss >500 mL and second-degree perineal tears8. In contrast, no consistent benefit or harm has been observed in those receiving epidural analgesia11. This divergence suggests that counseling should be tailored: for non-epidural women, education might emphasize labor acceleration and risk mitigation; for those with epidurals, the focus could shift toward safety, comfort, and realistic expectations. Yet, translating this into practice is not straightforward. Information gaps and entrenched cultural norms often hinder implementation. As Zang et al.50 found, many women weigh perceived risks more heavily than potential gains, and in certain traditional settings, supine birth remains culturally preferred. Various educational approaches have been used to convey this information, though evidence on their effectiveness remains limited51,52.

Selection and implementation of upright position in the second stage of labor

During the second stage of labor, current evidence supports prioritizing maternal preference for upright positioning while actively discouraging supine/semi-supine positions (Level 5b). When fetal manipulation or complications are not expected, women ought to be supported in choosing positions that feel most comfortable to them (Level 1c). Notably, given the possible increased risk of second-degree perineal laceration, evidence points out that midwives should provide women with comfortable labor positions while keeping genital structures clearly visible and taking measures to prevent perineal laceration (Level 1b). Timing also matters. Prolonged use of the birthing toilet (about 20 minutes) and continuous sitting or squatting positions can cause excessive pressure on the perineal interface (Level 1b). Positional rotation every 20–30 minutes during passive descent, particularly with delayed pushing, has been associated with reduced severe perineal trauma (Level 1c). Still, a notable gap remains: few studies specify the optimal duration of upright positioning during the second stage. This lack of clarity leaves room for individualized, rather than protocol-driven decision-making.

The birthing ball (alternatively termed exercise/Swiss ball) can help women adopt postures that are biomechanically favorable, particularly when used in supported kneeling or standing stances53. When hip flexion exceeds 100 degrees, the birthing ball has been shown to reduce lumbar strain by approximately one-third (Level 1a). Complementary use of the peanut ball expands pelvic inlet dimensions by maintaining 30 degrees hip abduction in lateral positions54.

For fetal heart rate abnormalities (less than 100 times/min or more than 160 times/min), left lateral positioning improves uteroplacental perfusion by reducing aortocaval compression (Level 5b). When there is a need for fetal manipulation or when optimal surgical exposure is anticipated, however, a semi-recumbent position (trunk tilted forwards up to 30 degrees to the horizontal) or lithotomy position is advantageous (Level 1c). Biomechanical reviews list squatting’s potential to increase efficiency of uterine contractions and improve fetal alignment and pelvic dimensions40. This postural shift mechanically supports cervical dilation and can help speed up delivery (Level 1c). Women with concomitant rheumatic heart disease are generally advised to bear down in the left lateral position rather than supine, as it lessens cardiovascular changes and improves preload. Prolonged lithotomy is contraindicated (Level 5b). Finally, for overweight pregnant women, midwives should encourage continued physical activity, but with built-in rest intervals. Given the extra physical demand, attention to psychological comfort and perceived exertion is just as important as the exercise itself (Level 5b).

Assessment and monitoring of upright labor position

Prior to implementing upright positions, comprehensive assessment of maternal physical capacity and obstetric requirements is recommended (Level 5b). When continuous monitoring allows, and no contraindications are present, frequent changes in position have been associated with improved maternal comfort and fetal alignment (Level 1b). Given the limited high-quality evidence on the safety of upright positions under epidural, close observation remains critical (Level 1c). Muscle strength assessment, such as leg resistance tests and walking tests, is crucial for pregnant women with epidural analgesia who intend to adopt an upright position (Level 5b). Women experiencing back pain require modified positioning approaches, as sustained upright postures (standing/sitting >30 minutes) may exacerbate discomfort (Level 2b).

Mobility remains a consideration of care during labor while using electronic fetal monitoring (EFM). When a woman chooses an upright posture, continuous assessment of fetal wellbeing is necessary (Level 1b). However, if a position impedes reliable EFM readings, the trade-offs should be communicated, and support for shifting to a monitor-friendly position may be provided (Level 5b). Conventional EFM may restrict mobility through wired connections, increasing maternal discomfort55. Unrestricted walking has been associated with enhanced perceived control and satisfaction, while limited mobility reduces positional options, elevates analgesia requirements, and raises intervention rates, including cesarean deliveries56.

Adequate support for labor in the upright position

Clinician philosophies influence intrapartum positioning recommendations, with midwives playing a role in supporting and ensuring proper upright position utilization through non-directive counselling and biomechanical support (Level 5b). Implementation barriers include clinicians’ knowledge gaps, safety concerns, unmet maternal needs, and insufficient training protocols (Level 4b). Health professionals who are used to supporting women to deliver in the lying-down position need to be trained on how to support an upright position (Level 5b). Family participation has been associated with enhanced maternal perceived control when coordinated with midwifery communication (Level 4b). The birth environment can support or hinder physiological birth. A calm atmosphere can reduce stress hormones. Closed doors, dim lighting, and home-like comforts have been reported as potentially comforting (Level 5b). Thus, a comfortable space and adequate equipment need to be provided to support the use of active positioning and movement, such as bed rails, birthing chairs or stools, birthing balls, cushions, etc. (Level 1b). The use of equipment can help a pregnant woman relax while making multiple position changes. Minimize environmental distractions during upright labor and allow for rest breaks between positions (Level 5b).

Limitations

Although this study summarized more comprehensive evidence on the management of the second stage of labor in the upright position, fewer high-quality original studies were included. Therefore, the findings should be interpreted with caution. None of the included literature introduced the researchers, so the multicultural background, values, and regional ethnic variability of the study population may have influenced the results. Furthermore, we only included eligible reviews published in English and Chinese, which may have omitted some eligible reviews published in other languages. We did not perform a meta-analysis, as the included sources consisted primarily of clinical practice guidelines, evidence summaries, and systematic reviews that were not amenable to quantitative synthesis. The results were synthesized descriptively. Moreover, publication bias cannot be ruled out, as studies with non-significant or unfavorable findings may be under-represented.

CONCLUSION

This study synthesizes 35 pieces of evidence across nine domains (education, selection, implementation, assessment and monitoring, staff training, midwife assistance, family engagement, facility configuration, and environment creation) to guide upright positioning during second-stage labor. It provides an evidence-based basis for healthcare professionals and midwives to help pregnant women adopt the upright position. While strongly recommending upright positioning adoption, standardization gaps persist regarding optimal implementation frequency/duration and operational protocols. Future multicenter trials should establish practice guidelines through expanded sampling and quality improvement initiatives.